Is Income Protection Insurance Tax Deductible for the Self Employed

---

Understanding the tax implications of various insurance policies can be a complex area for self-employed individuals in the UK. When it comes to income protection and key person insurance, the rules are nuanced, primarily revolving around HMRC’s ‘wholly and exclusively’ rule.

Standard Income Protection Insurance

For the vast majority of self-employed individuals, the premiums paid for a standard income protection insurance policy are not tax-deductible as a business expense. This is because HMRC views such policies as providing a personal benefit rather than a direct business one.

The ‘Wholly and Exclusively’ Rule

To be considered an allowable business expense, an cost must be incurred ‘wholly and exclusively’ for the purposes of the trade or business. A standard income protection policy is designed to replace your personal income if you are unable to work due to illness or injury. The payout is intended to cover your personal living expenses, such as mortgage payments, utility bills, and food, rather than the operational costs or lost profits of your business. Therefore, it fails the ‘wholly and exclusively’ test as it primarily benefits you as an individual, not the business entity itself [1].

Tax Treatment of Payouts

A significant consequence of premiums not being tax-deductible is that any payout received from a personal income protection policy is typically tax-free. This balances the tax treatment, as you’ve paid the premiums from your post-tax income.

Key Person Insurance

Key Person Insurance (sometimes called Key Man Insurance) presents a different scenario, but for self-employed individuals operating as sole traders, it generally faces the same hurdle regarding tax deductibility.

Purpose of Key Person Insurance

Key Person Insurance is designed to protect a business from the financial loss it would suffer if a crucial individual (the ‘key person’) were to become critically ill, disabled, or die. The policy aims to compensate the business for lost profits, the cost of recruiting a replacement, or the disruption caused by the key person’s absence.

Why it’s Difficult for Sole Traders

For a sole trader, the individual is the business. There is no legal distinction between the two. If the sole trader (the key person) is incapacitated or dies, the business often ceases to exist or is severely impacted in a way that makes it difficult to argue the policy is ‘wholly and exclusively’ for the business’s ongoing trade. Any payout is typically seen as compensating the individual or their estate, rather than making good a loss of business profits in an ongoing entity.

When Key Person Insurance Can Be Deductible

Key Person Insurance premiums are more commonly tax-deductible for businesses with a separate legal identity, such as limited companies or partnerships. In these structures, the policy can be an allowable expense if it meets strict HMRC criteria, including:

•The policy’s sole purpose is to cover a loss of business profits or revenue for the company/partnership.

•The policy is a short-term, term assurance policy, not a whole-of-life policy.

•The business (company or partnership) is the beneficiary of the policy, not the individual’s family.

•The policy is not a disguised form of remuneration for the employee or owner.

Conclusion

In summary, while the concept of protecting your income or business is vital for the self-employed, the tax deductibility of insurance premiums in the UK is highly dependent on the type of policy and the legal structure of your business. Standard income protection is generally a personal expense, and for sole traders, Key Person Insurance on oneself also typically falls into this category. Always consult with a qualified tax advisor for advice tailored to your specific circumstances.

References

[1] HMRC Internal Manuals, Business Income Manual, BIM45560 – Specific deductions: insurance: own health policies and others. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/business-income-manual/bim45560

---